Hot topics

You don't need a bigger phone

sony xperia z4 tablet as phone de cropped
© nextpit

OK, it's official. Smartphones are too big. Every year, manufacturers make bigger phones, and consumers line up for them. But, bigger isn't always better, people. At this rate, we'll be using smartphones as big as houses within 10 years. It's madness. Do you really need a bigger phone every year?

Your pockets are too small

Either pockets need to get bigger, or phones need to get smaller. Trying to sit down with a phone in your pocket has become impossible. To illustrate my point, here's a fun story:

When I put the average-sized 5.2-inch Moto X (2nd Gen) in my pocket and tried to sit down, guess what happened? My pants ripped as I tumbled over. So, for some of us, the average size is too large. But, as I said, phones get bigger every year. The next generation of the Moto X produced the whopping 5.7-inch phablet Moto X Pure. At a whole half-inch bigger than the phone that caused my pants to rip, I wouldn't recommend you put this one in your pocket either. Nor can I recommend trying to use the phone one-handed, and I say this as someone with big hands.

androidpit android phone pocket
Your pockets might be too small for a bigger phone. / © NextPit

Your hands are too small

Products and tools that are meant to be used with human hands tend to be sized for, you guessed it, human hands. You can expect books, scissors, door handles and steering wheels to be of a certain consistent size. Scissors don't get bigger every year. Though for some reason smartphones do, despite the fact that the average male's hands remain a consistent 8.1 inches every year.

Scissors don't get bigger every year, so why do phones?

At what point is it enough? Either when manufacturers get the point, or when humans evolve into giants. Until then, we should accept that our hands simply aren't big enough to operate ever-larger smartphones.

androidpit samsung galaxy note 5 37
If you need a stylus, it's not really a phone anymore. / © NextPit

Your face is too small

Let's face it, every phone that came after the 4-inch Galaxy S was too big to comfortably make phone calls. Not too big to actually call someone, but rather too big to make calls and not look as though you're playing hide-and-seek. Remember when making calls with a sleek new phone used to look cool?

Making calls with a smartphone used to look cool

Your face is too small for phones to get bigger. Whether you're fashion conscious, or even just conscious, there comes a point at which phones are simply too big to make calls comfortably and without looking like a big dork. But, do you make calls that often anymore? There's a reason why a majority of our communication is done via WhatsApp, Facebook Messenger and email. Phones are just too big to put up against our faces nowadays.

Think about downsizing

Should you buy a larger phone every time you upgrade? This is something to factor into your purchasing decision. Think about the practicality of its size and imagine, if you go on-contract, what it'll be like carrying a giant brick in your pocket every day for two years. Think about the story I told you, and ask yourself, "Can my pockets handle the phone without ripping?"

Opt for the 5-inch Google Pixel instead of the 5.5-inch Pixel XL. Or, go even smaller with the 4.6-inch Xperia X Compact.

AndroidPIT huawei mate 9 0144
You don't need a giant 6-inch Huawei Mate 9. / © NextPit

For me, around five inches is about perfect. For you, a phablet like the 5.5-inch OnePlus 3T might be best, if you're a giant. But, I urge you to think about whether you really need a bigger phone, because I doubt your face and hands are getting bigger every year.

When is enough, enough? What's your optimal phone size? Let me know in the comments.

  Editor's choice Best smart home control center Best price-performance ratio Best sound Best sound supplement Best display
Product
Product image Amazon Echo Dot (5. Gen) 2022 Product Image Amazon Echo Hub Product Image Amazon Echo (4.Gen) Product Image Amazon Echo Studio Product Image Amazon Echo Sub Product Image Amazon Echo Show 10 (3rd. Gen) Product Image
Review
Review: Amazon Echo Dot (5. Gen) 2022
Review: Amazon Echo Hub
Not yet tested
Review: Amazon Echo Studio
Not yet tested
Not yet tested
Price Compariosn
Go to comment (72)
Omar Hamwi

Omar Hamwi
Head of Content

Omar has been a dedicated Android user since 2011. He began his career as a print journalist before a move into digital editing. He is passionate about technology and, since relocating from Sydney to Berlin, now shares his passion as part of the AndroidPIT team. His mission now is to help readers of AndroidPIT find the best hardware and software.

Liked this article? Share now!
Recommended articles
Latest articles
Push notification Next article
72 comments
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing

  • 2
    Martin Hamilton Jan 12, 2018 Link to comment

    I had a 5-inch regular Z1 on a 2-year contract but after 14 months I wanted out. Bigger screens would be OK if the bezels didn't make the whole phone so big. The S8 seems too long.
    I now have a 4-inch iPhone SE and am still surprised by how easy and ergonomic it is to use. The keyboard is small but glide typing with Gboard takes care of texting. There is such a thing as big enough. For now, with the phones currently available, I will not sacrifice compactness.
    My 4.6-inch Z5 Compact was absolutely perfect and I would never want more. The bezels were beautifully small.


  • 27
    Sorin Jan 5, 2018 Link to comment

    For those who are truly passionate about large diagonals, they can use a 10 "tablet as a handset, and then they even solve all the chores, or just as well for those who truly love big diagonals are the 24" you practically use a TV for your phone calls.
    My personal opinion is that a 5.5 "diagonal is enough for anyone who wants a relatively large screen, or a maximum of 5.7 or maybe 6" for 18: 9 screen phones, in which case the edges of the screen be very narrow. I can see that the trend is big diagonal, about 5.5 ", a diagonal that offers good quality to read various information. For general use, even 5 to 5.2" screen phones are very practical and very easy to use with one hand.
    It's just a taste of taste.


  • 2
    Salvador Bento Jan 4, 2017 Link to comment

    Well, after the death of my Z3 Compact 4 days ago, I had no choice but to buy a big one yesterday, because Z5C is almost the same thing as Z3C in hardware and expensive (sony totally screw it), and Xperia XC is too expensive in my country.
    The other small phones are too weak in hardware, so I had to move from a 4.5 inch to a 5.5 inch phone (Moto Z play).
    I do not know how I am going to handle that since I hate these big screens (and my hands are small if compared to man average hands size). Unfortunatelly it was the only option with a current acceptable hardware which I could afford. My friend has a Z3 5.2 inch, for me it is big, not outrageously big, but big.
    I hope I will get used to it. As long as it fits in my pockets (I hate have to carry any kind of bag, men usually do), I think it will do fine.
    I'm still waiting the delivery.

    I don't blame the manufacturers for doing big phones, because in fact they should. But I like the high performance and small screens (anything between 4.5 and 5). The sad part is, the only flagships in small size today are with Sony. If you want to reduce size in other manufacturers, you also drastically reduce hardware .
    The day when technology allow us to completely fold our phones, I think it will be great, I will not complain anymore. :)


  • John Kerr 5
    John Kerr Dec 21, 2016 Link to comment

    For me 5.7 inches was perfect. That phone has since been recalled and a 5.5 inch Edge is standing in until the S8 Edge or Note 8 is available. As for too big, I'm always using Bluetooth and hold my phone like a tablet - using both hands most of the time. Considering the studies that talk about how filthy an average phone screen is, who wants that next to their face anyway?


  • 5
    C H Dec 20, 2016 Link to comment

    5.0" is too big, bring back 4.5". I need a replacement for my 1st generation Moto X and there is nothing available that size on verizon. I don't watch videos or play games and I prefer to use my phone one handed. I am a big guy (6'3") but I like small phones.

    Martin Hamilton


    • Pandhêga Palibaya 1
      Pandhêga Palibaya Jan 15, 2017 Link to comment

      Moto X (1st generation) is the best smartphone I ever had. The display position is the best, and also the best design for hand.


  • 13
    Dazzler Dec 19, 2016 Link to comment

    For me, it's got to be 5.5 inches or bigger. I've got the S7 Edge, which is perfect because it has a high screen to body ratio thanks to the curved edges. It's not bulky like the Iphone Plus and has the haptic and physical home buttons so even the bit beneath the screen is usefull space.

    I honestly couldn't go back to a smaller, non curved phone easily!

    nightflyer2131


    • Brittany McGhee 21
      Brittany McGhee Dec 20, 2016 Link to comment

      Thanks for sharing your opinion! Do you use a headset when you make calls? Or do you hold the phone up to your ear?


  • Andria D. 11
    Andria D. Dec 19, 2016 Link to comment

    I just got a ZTE Zmax Pro, a whopping 6" "phablet". I LOVE IT! For one thing, now I don't feel that I'm just speaking out into the air, but actually INTO THE PHONE. I always hated that about tiny smartphones. For another very important point... I really hate, loathe, and despise phones and phone calls; I can forgive mine for being a phone, because it's actually a computer -- which I love! It may be huge as phones go, but it's quite small, as computers go; it's considerably smaller than my 7" Samsung tablet, and MUCH faster, being an octa-core; it may even be faster than my dual-core i5 laptop PC -- which can't make phone calls. But anyone who says that a 6" phone is huge apparently doesn't recall when phones were metal, were attached to the wall, actually *dialed*, and made a "scritch" sound while doing it. THOSE phone handsets were huge, and also heavy -- probably about the same weight as my 6" handheld computer with case and glass screen protector... which also happens to be a phone.

    Brittany McGhee


    • Brittany McGhee 21
      Brittany McGhee Dec 20, 2016 Link to comment

      Andria, I remember the funny old days of huge landline phones mounted on the wall. We're so lucky to live in a time when we have phones/computers that can fit in our pockets (and the option to text instead of making dreaded phone calls!). Thanks for your comment!

      Andria D.


      • 28
        itprolonden Dec 21, 2016 Link to comment

        Still, nothing conveys your feelings like a phone call. My family would rather receive a thoughtful call than a cold text.

        Brittany McGhee


      • Andria D. 11
        Andria D. Dec 25, 2016 Link to comment

        Most of my family wouldn't know what to do with a text. ;) But it's better to text my husband at work, if it's not terribly important -- hate to interrupt him at work just to tell him to stop by Kroger on the way home. :D But speaking as a relative newcomer to smartphones... it took me only a few weeks to be really glad for the nifty computer in my purse, if I needed to look up a location, or whatever. I resisted mobile phones till May of this year, but I'm a complete convert -- which is why it took only 7 months to go from a 4.5" budget phone, to a 6" "phablet" with considerably more power and speed.

        Brittany McGhee


  • Attila Ferenczi 7
    Attila Ferenczi Dec 18, 2016 Link to comment

    My opinion is that an ideal phone should be between 5 and 5.5 inches. With a screen that big you can easily enjoy media, games and maybe everything that you do with your phone. But if your hands are smaller and these phones are maybe too bulky for you than you should take a smaller device, or if you prefer to watch movies and a lot of youtube than you should aim for a bigger screen.
    Manufacturers made phones in all sizes, styles and functions so that we the costumers can freely choose the one that fits best our needs and taste. It is true that you can make a standard size that would fit everybodys needs but the best thing is that you dont have to. You can choose whatever phone you like and that is why I like android phones so much, because there is a phone for every user no matter the price or size or UI or whatever people are looking for in a new phone.

    Brittany McGheeAndria D.


    • Brittany McGhee 21
      Brittany McGhee Dec 20, 2016 Link to comment

      You're right, one of the best things about Android is that there's something for everyone!


  • 1
    Deactivated Account Dec 18, 2016 Link to comment

    Omar Hamwi perhaps have small pockets and small hands? My trusty old z ultra fits fine in my regular pants.. in my hands and to my face.. 6,4 Inch screen 18 x 9 cm ~ 7 x 3,5 inch.


  • 4
    David Berk Dec 18, 2016 Link to comment

    My current phone is 5.2, will go for a 5.5 next time. Being able to see the screen is the most important thing.
    You can squint, I have old eyes and don't want or need to.

    Andria D.


  • 4
    Ivor Tollah Dec 18, 2016 Link to comment

    No one ever went to their grave wishing they had a smaller phone.


  • Diptangshu M. 15
    Diptangshu M. Dec 17, 2016 Link to comment

    5 inch all the way.


  • Taoufiq Lak 14
    Taoufiq Lak Dec 17, 2016 Link to comment

    For me I find that the Galaxy S4 is the best phone from it's size and feeling of the touch, I tried many phones ( big new ones ) but I downgraded back to the 5.0 inch Galaxy S4. And for those who read and say wtf is this guy saying the Galaxy s4 is a 2013 phone get the hell out of there, I say that I customized the ROM as I want it to be ;) Any way this is to support the opinion of 5.0 inch phones are the best to handle.


  • 5
    andy Dec 17, 2016 Link to comment

    I want a bigger phone than my one plus one as my eyes are f@cked ,the only thing that keeps growing is my ears and eye brows 😨😨

    nightflyer2131

Show all comments
Write new comment:
All changes will be saved. No drafts are saved when editing